Troubleshooting Low Open/Click Rates

Low open rates (percentage of delivered emails opened) and click-through rates (percentage of delivered emails clicked) can indicate problems with deliverability, engagement, or both. Here's a breakdown of potential causes and how to address them:

Potential Causes for Low Open Rates:

• Deliverability Issues (Landing in Spam): Even if marked "Delivered", your emails might be going straight to the spam folder where they're unlikely to be opened.
  • Solution: Verify your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly set up. Improve your sender reputation by warming up senders, cleaning lists, and sending engaging content. Avoid spam trigger words.
• Weak Subject Lines: Your subject line isn't compelling enough to make recipients want to open the email.
  • Solution: Write clear, concise, and benefit-driven subject lines. Personalize them using tags (, ). Test different approaches (e.g., question vs. statement, urgency vs. curiosity). Use the Subject Line Tester.
• Poor Sender Recognition: The "From Name" and "From Email" address aren't recognizable or trustworthy to the recipient.
  • Solution: Use a clear and recognizable From Name (e.g., "Your Name at Company" or "Company Name"). Send from a professional domain email address, not a free address like @gmail.com or @outlook.com for business communication.
• Bad Timing: Sending emails when your audience is least likely to check their inbox.
  • Solution: Research your audience or experiment with sending at different times of day and days of the week. Consider using sending windows within BuffSend.
• List Quality / Targeting: Sending to uninterested or irrelevant contacts.
  • Solution: Clean your list of unengaged contacts. Improve your targeting and segmentation to ensure you're reaching the right audience.
• Inaccurate Open Tracking: As noted in the analytics guide, open tracking isn't perfect (image blocking, MPP). Rely more on clicks as a true engagement metric.

Potential Causes for Low Click-Through Rates (CTR / CTOR):

(Assuming opens are happening, but clicks are low)

• Weak Call-to-Action (CTA): It's not clear what you want the recipient to do, or the CTA isn't compelling.
  • Solution: Use clear, action-oriented language (e.g., "Book a Demo", "Download the Guide", "Learn More"). Make CTA buttons prominent and visually distinct. Ensure the value proposition for clicking is clear.
• Irrelevant Content/Offer: The email content doesn't match the recipient's needs or interests, or the offer isn't valuable to them.
  • Solution: Improve list segmentation and content personalization. Ensure your offer directly addresses a pain point or goal of your target audience.
• Poor Email Design/Layout: The email is hard to read, links are difficult to find, or it doesn't render well on mobile devices.
  • Solution: Use clear formatting (headings, short paragraphs, bullet points). Ensure links are obvious (buttons or clearly styled text links). Test email rendering on different devices and email clients.
• Too Many Choices: Including too many different links or CTAs can confuse the reader and dilute focus.
  • Solution: Focus each email on one primary goal and CTA if possible.
• Broken Links: Links might be incorrectly formatted or lead to non-existent pages.
  • Solution: Always test all links in your emails before sending a campaign.

Improving open and click rates often involves a combination of technical fixes (deliverability), strategic adjustments (targeting, timing), and creative improvements (subject lines, content, CTAs). Continuously test and analyze your results to find what resonates best with your audience.

← Back to Knowledge Base